
Embodied carbon, the often-overlooked greenhouse gas emissions associated with building materials, is a significant contributor to climate change. California is leading the charge in addressing this issue with ambitious regulations, setting stringent requirements for embodied carbon reduction in construction.
This blog post breaks down what embodied carbon is, why it matters to developers, and how California’s regulatory landscape is evolving. We also explore how Carbon Wise can help you navigate these complexities and enhance your project’s sustainability profile.
Understanding Embodied Carbon: The Hidden Footprint
- Embodied carbon refers to the greenhouse gas emissions associated with the entire lifecycle of building materials. This includes extraction, manufacturing, transportation, construction, and decommissioning.
- Think of it as the “upfront” carbon footprint of your building, separate from the operational energy use.
- Embodied carbon is determined by a product’s Global Warming Potential (GWP), which is the amount of greenhouse gas emissions, expressed in kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent (kg-CO2e), released per unit of product (either by weight or area) across its lifecycle stages.
- Note: embodied emissions account for 11% of global CO2 emissions.
Why it’s “hidden”:
- Unlike readily visible operational energy (e.g. electricity and heating), embodied carbon remains largely unseen. It’s dispersed across complex supply chains, from raw material extraction to building decommissioning, making it difficult to track and measure.
- Embodied carbon emissions are “locked in up front”, becoming a fixed part of a building’s footprint at construction. These upfront emissions, particularly from materials like cement and steel, have an immediate and long-term climate impact.
- Note: Even in highly efficient buildings, it can take up to 150 years of operational efficiency to offset the impacts of upfront embodied carbon emissions.
Why Embodied Carbon Matters: A Developer's Perspective
- Compliance: California is leading the way, setting ambitious targets for embodied carbon reduction (explained below). Projects that don’t meet these standards may not even receive the necessary permits to begin construction. Avoid costly setbacks and ensure your project complies with the latest regulations.
- Sustainability Profile: Enhance your project’s appeal and value. Today’s buyers and investors are increasingly prioritizing sustainability. A low embodied carbon footprint can be a key differentiator, attracting tenants and commanding higher prices.
- Cost Savings: Reduce both upfront and long-term costs. Optimizing material use and minimizing waste reduces initial expenses. Choosing durable, low-carbon materials can also lower maintenance and replacement costs over the building’s life cycle.
- Marketing Tool: Tap into the growing market for green buildings. Showcase your project’s low carbon footprint to attract environmentally conscious buyers and gain a competitive edge in the market.
California's Regulatory Landscape: A Timeline of Change
Assembly Bill No. 2446 (AB 2446)
-
- Scope: The bill applies to the construction of new buildings, including residential buildings.
- Goal: To significantly reduce embodied carbon emissions associated with building materials in California, aligning with the state’s goal of carbon neutrality by 2045.
- Mandate: Requires the California Air Resources Board (CARB)7 to develop a framework for measuring and reducing embodied carbon by July 1, 2025.
- Targets: Sets ambitious reduction targets:
- 40% net reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from building materials by 2035.
- Interim target of 20% by 2030 (eliminated in AB 43).
- Baseline: The baseline for these reductions will be determined using industry average data from 2026.
- Read more here.
Assembly Bill No. 43 (AB 43)
-
- Scope: Amends and adds to existing law (AB 2446) related to reducing greenhouse gas emissions associated with building materials in California.
- Goal: To further support the reduction of embodied carbon in building materials by authorizing an embodied carbon trading system. This would allow market-based exchange of emissions credits with a target implementation of January 1, 2029.
- Mandate: Authorizes the California Air Resources Board (CARB) to establish an embodied carbon trading system8.
- Targets: Maintains the target of 40% net reduction in greenhouse gas emissions from building materials by 2035, but removes the interim target of 20% by 2030.
- Baseline: Provides flexibility for CARB to determine the baseline for emissions reductions based on either 2026 industry average data or the most relevant, up-to-date information available.
- Read more here.
CALGreen 2022 (effective July 1, 2024)
-
- Scope: Applies to large non-residential buildings (over 100,000 sq ft) and school projects (over 50,000 sq ft), encompassing both new construction and adaptive reuse.
- Goal: To minimize building-related environmental impact by reducing embodied carbon emissions through promoting lower-carbon materials, encouraging structural reuse, and establishing a pathway for industry-wide global warming potential reduction.
- Mandate: The CALGreen 2022 Intervening Code Adoption Cycle mandates embodied carbon reductions for applicable building projects and enforces agencies to verify compliance through inspections and reports.
- Targets: Offers three pathways for compliance and highlights specific GWP limits for materials like concrete, steel, glass, and mineral wool insulation
- Building Reuse: Mandatory 45% reuse of existing structure and enclosure, with voluntary tiers of 75%, or 75% + 30% interior reuse. Combining reuse with new building, limits the addition area to 200% of the existing building area.
- WB-LCA9: Mandatory 10% reduction in GWP from baseline, with voluntary tiers of 15% and 20%. Path requires a 60 year cradle-to-grave WB-LCA to be conducted according to ISO 14044.
- Prescriptive Path: Mandatory 175% of IW-EPD10 GWP Limits for specific materials, with voluntary tiers of 150% or within IW-EPD GWP Limits.
Looking Ahead: Future Regulations and Frameworks
Building codes and environmental regulations are constantly evolving. California is likely to continue strengthening its embodied carbon regulations. While CALGreen’s immediate focus in the July 1, 2024, update is on larger non-residential and school projects, AB 2446 clearly sets the stage for increased LCA requirements in residential construction. Therefore, the target for LCA on residential is tied to the deadlines that AB 2446 set forth, and the resulting frameworks that are produced.
Potential Future Targets:
- Expanding Scope: Future regulations could expand the scope of embodied carbon requirements to include smaller buildings and residential projects.
- Lowering Thresholds: Expect to see the GWP limits within the prescriptive path become more strict over time.
- Life Cycle Assessments: There is a strong possibility of increased requirements for whole building life cycle assessments.
- Material Specific Regulations: Further regulations on specific high carbon foot print materials may restrict their use, in favor of bio-based alternatives.
How We Can Help: Your Partner in Embodied Carbon Compliance
- Precisely Assess Embodied Carbon: We leverage our LCA expertise and advanced modeling tools to accurately measure your project’s full lifecycle embodied carbon footprint.
- Develop Tailored Reduction Strategies: We collaborate with you to identify optimal solutions for reducing embodied carbon, including material selection, structural optimization, and innovative construction techniques.
- Navigate Evolving Regulations: With in-depth knowledge of policies across jurisdictions, we ensure your projects comply with current and anticipated embodied carbon regulations.
- Enhance Project Value: We help you communicate your sustainability achievements to stakeholders, showcasing your commitment to a low-carbon future and enhancing project value.
Contact us for a free consultation so we can best recommend the solutions that fit with your home’s needs.